Sammy Hagar Says Glen Ballard Wrote the Most Insulting Van Halen Song He Ever Sang

A Band That Could Turn on Itself

Any band built like Van Halen could feel like a troubled marriage at times. When things worked, the chemistry felt unbeatable. When cracks appeared, they spread fast. During Sammy Hagar’s years as frontman, he often came across as the calmer presence compared to David Lee Roth. Still, that did not protect him from sharp conflicts behind the scenes.

Hagar joined the band with good intentions and a clear desire to move things forward. He wanted Van Halen to grow while keeping its core sound strong. The group did stretch musically during his era, but that growth came with tension. Small disagreements often became personal, especially once new management entered the picture and shifted the balance of power.

Management Changes and Growing Friction

The trouble deepened during the period surrounding 5150. Hagar’s manager stepped into a bigger role, which quickly caused friction. While that manager had success with bands like Rush, Hagar felt he was not the right fit for Van Halen. At the same time, this shift allowed other members to gain more control over songwriting decisions.

That change altered the band’s internal trust. Hagar had always believed the group worked best when ideas stayed within the band. Outside influence, especially on lyrics, felt like crossing a line. As management gained more say, Hagar sensed his role becoming less secure, even though he was still the lead singer.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Glen Ballard (@glen.ballard)

Creative Control Slips Away

By the time Balance was taking shape, the band felt divided. The album leaned heavily in certain directions, and compromise became rare. Eddie Van Halen, in particular, showed little interest in meeting halfway. One disagreement even led to a song being stripped of vocals and turned into an instrumental.

The real breaking point came when Eddie brought in an outside songwriter. For Hagar, this was not about ego. It was about trust. Van Halen had always written its own story. Inviting someone else into that process made Hagar feel pushed aside in his own band.

Outside Writers Were Not New, but This Was Different

Using outside writers was not unheard of in rock. Aerosmith worked with Desmond Child, and bands like Bon Jovi often welcomed help. Hagar understood that. Still, Van Halen felt different to him. As the singer, he believed in standing behind every word he sang.

That belief clashed hard when a song called “Between Us Two” entered the picture. Hagar learned that all of his lyrics had been removed and replaced with words written by Glen Ballard. The topic alone caught him off guard, but the way it happened cut deeper.

The Song That Crossed the Line

Hagar did not hide his anger when recalling the moment. He explained exactly how it unfolded, saying, “I asked him what the song was about, and he said Glen had written about an escaped convict from a mental institution. I paused for a moment to catch my breath and told him, ’That’s the lyrical treatment Glen came up with? First of all, that’s a fucking insult. The lyrics I wrote for that song are great, and for you to go to somebody else I’ve never even met and say he can write lyrics to my song sucks. Fuck you! He can sing them too!’”

The reaction showed how deeply personal the issue was for Hagar. It was not just about one song. It was about respect and creative ownership.

Why the Lyrics Mattered So Much

Hagar never denied Glen Ballard’s talent. Ballard later became widely known for major projects like Jagged Little Pill. Still, Hagar felt the direction did not fit what he wanted to express at that time. He preferred writing from his own experience rather than singing a dark concept chosen by someone else.

He believed the song could have become something powerful in its own way, but only if it felt real to him. For Hagar, singing words he did not connect with defeated the purpose of being a frontman. If the singer cannot believe the song, the music suffers.

A Lesson in Band Dynamics

The situation summed up a larger issue within Van Halen. Bands rely on compromise, but they also depend on trust. Once that trust fades, even strong partnerships struggle. Hagar’s frustration showed how quickly creative decisions can turn personal when communication breaks down.

In the end, the dispute over one song reflected a bigger divide. It highlighted how far apart the band members had grown and how difficult it had become to agree on a shared voice.