9 Times Rock Bands’ Comeback Singles Missed the Mark

Classic rock bands often attempt comebacks, aiming to reconnect with fans and recapture their earlier success. However, not all return efforts resonate as intended. Here are nine instances where comeback singles fell short of expectations.​

1. Kiss – “Psycho Circus” (1998)

In 1998, Kiss released “Psycho Circus,” marking the return of their original lineup. The single debuted at number three on the Billboard 200, selling 110,000 copies in its first week and earning a gold certification. Despite commercial success, critics offered mixed reviews. Rolling Stone described it as “an album of platform-stomping rhythms,” while others felt it lacked the authenticity of their earlier work. ​

2. Pixies – “Bagboy” (2013)

After a long hiatus, the Pixies released “Bagboy” in 2013, their first new song in nearly a decade. The track featured familiar elements of their sound, but longtime fans were disappointed by the absence of bassist Kim Deal. Although the song generated initial excitement, it didn’t sustain momentum, and the subsequent album, “Indie Cindy,” received mixed reviews. Many felt the band’s comeback lacked the innovation and edge that had defined their earlier work.​

3. The Doors – “The Doors of the 21st Century” (2002)

Following Jim Morrison’s death, The Doors attempted a revival in 2002 with new members, including Ian Astbury on vocals. Renamed “The Doors of the 21st Century,” the group faced legal challenges over the use of the original name. Despite their efforts, the new lineup couldn’t capture the essence of the original band, and fans were largely uninterested. The project eventually dissolved, highlighting the difficulties of reviving a band without its iconic frontman.​

4. Smashing Pumpkins – “Tarantula” (2007)

Billy Corgan reformed Smashing Pumpkins in 2007, releasing the album “Zeitgeist” with only drummer Jimmy Chamberlin from the original lineup. The lead single, “Tarantula,” aimed to reestablish the band’s presence but failed to resonate with audiences. Critics pointed out the absence of key members and a lack of the band’s signature sound. The album’s performance was underwhelming, and the comeback didn’t restore the band’s former prominence. ​

5. Bauhaus – “Go Away White” (2008)

Goth rock pioneers Bauhaus reunited in 2008 to release “Go Away White,” their first album in 25 years. The comeback was short-lived, as the band announced their breakup shortly after the album’s release. The music deviated from their classic style, leaving fans confused and disappointed. Without a supporting tour, the album failed to make a lasting impression, and the reunion was deemed unsuccessful. ​

6. Bad English – “Forget Me Not” (1989)

Formed by members of Journey and The Babys, Bad English released “Forget Me Not” as their debut single in 1989. Despite the band’s pedigree, the song only reached number 45 on the Billboard Hot 100. It wasn’t until their second single, “When I See You Smile,” that they achieved significant success. The initial underperformance of “Forget Me Not” highlighted the challenges supergroups face in meeting high expectations.​

7. No Doubt – “Ex-Girlfriend” (2000)

After the massive success of “Tragic Kingdom,” No Doubt’s 2000 single “Ex-Girlfriend” marked a shift to a darker, more introspective sound. The song failed to chart on the Billboard Hot 100, signaling a decline in the band’s mainstream appeal. While the accompanying album, “Return of Saturn,” received critical acclaim, it didn’t match the commercial success of its predecessor. The band’s attempt to evolve their sound didn’t resonate with a broader audience. ​

8. The Alarm – “45 RPM” (2004)

Welsh band The Alarm attempted a comeback in 2004 with the single “45 RPM,” released under the pseudonym The Poppyfields. The song initially gained traction, but when the true identity of the band was revealed, interest waned. The stunt highlighted the challenges older bands face in reintroducing themselves to a new generation. Despite the clever marketing, the single didn’t lead to a sustained resurgence for the band. ​

9. Alice Cooper Band – “Black Mamba” (2025)

In 2025, the original Alice Cooper Band reunited to release “Black Mamba,” their first new song together in over 50 years. Despite the historical significance, the track received mixed reviews, with some fans feeling it lacked the energy of their earlier work. The song’s release was part of a larger album project, but it didn’t achieve significant commercial success. The comeback highlighted the difficulties legacy bands face in recapturing their past glory. ​