7 Rock Bands with the Worst Drummers Who Never Improved Over Time

​Throughout rock history, certain bands have faced criticism due to their drummers’ performances, which some argue did not evolve over time. This article examines seven such instances, culminating with Lars Ulrich of Metallica.​

7. The Shaggs – Helen Wiggin

The Shaggs, a band formed by the Wiggin sisters in 1965, are often cited for their unconventional musical style. Their drumming, handled by Helen Wiggin, was characterized by erratic rhythms and unpredictable time signatures. Critics have described their music as lacking traditional structure, leading to polarized opinions. Despite these critiques, The Shaggs have garnered a cult following, with some listeners appreciating their raw and unfiltered approach to music. ​

6. New York Dolls – Jerry Nolan

Emerging from New York City’s early ’70s scene, the New York Dolls were known for their raw sound and chaotic energy. While their drummer, Jerry Nolan, brought a distinctive style to the band, some critics felt that the drumming lacked precision and consistency. This unpolished approach contributed to the band’s rebellious image but also drew criticism regarding musical proficiency. ​

5. Pete Best (The Beatles)

Pete Best served as the original drummer for The Beatles before being replaced by Ringo Starr in 1962. According to various accounts, including statements from the band members, Best’s drumming was considered limited and lacking the versatility needed for the group’s evolving sound. John Lennon and Paul McCartney have both indicated that Best’s skills did not meet the band’s requirements, leading to his dismissal. ​

4. The Rolling Stones – Charlie Watts

Charlie Watts, though respected, had a drumming style that some perceived as laid-back. His straightforward approach contrasted with the more flamboyant styles of his contemporaries. However, his steady rhythm section was crucial to the band’s enduring sound.​

3. Lars Ulrich (Metallica)

Lars Ulrich, drummer for Metallica, has faced criticism over the years regarding his drumming abilities. Early producer Flemming Rasmussen noted challenges with Ulrich’s timing during the recording of “Ride the Lightning,” describing his initial performances as problematic. Despite these critiques, Ulrich has expressed contentment with his role in the band, emphasizing his understanding of Metallica’s musical dynamics. ​

2. Nirvana – Chad Channing

Chad Channing was Nirvana’s original drummer, playing on their debut album, “Bleach.” While he provided a solid foundation, his drumming was often overshadowed by the band’s explosive sound. He was eventually replaced by Dave Grohl, whose dynamic style became integral to Nirvana’s success. Channing’s tenure remains a footnote in the band’s legacy.​

1. AC/DC – Phil Rudd

Phil Rudd’s drumming is often described as simple yet effective. His no-frills approach provided a solid backbone for AC/DC’s rock anthems. While some critics viewed his style as unremarkable, fans appreciated its consistency and reliability.