The Classic Rock Legends That Were Better Of In Bands

Almost every musician who wants to be successful thinks about going solo. It sounds nice to make it big just by using your skill and hard work, but that’s not usually how it works. Going it alone isn’t always the best way to go ahead. Some musicians actually shine more when they’re in a band.

It can make a big difference to be around other creative people. When people share their ideas, gain feedback, and build on each other’s talents, they typically create something far bigger than what one person can do alone. As Ringo famously sang, sometimes you really do get by with a little help from your friends.

That’s exactly what this list highlights — three classic rock solo artists who, despite their individual talent, were even better when they played with a band.

Paul McCartney
Paul McCartney’s solo career is impressive, but let’s be real—how do you top The Beatles? It’s practically impossible. While McCartney found success on his own and with Wings, he never quite captured the same creative spark he had alongside John Lennon. That partnership was pure magic, balancing each other perfectly in ways few artists ever experience. Of course, that didn’t stop McCartney from writing classics like “Maybe I’m Amazed” in 1970. Still, those timeless Beatles tracks with Lennon and the rest of the band? They remain untouchable.

Sting
Sting’s solo career gave us gems like “Fields of Gold” and “Englishman in New York,” but there was something extra special about his time with The Police. As part of the band, his music had a sharper edge and a certain fire that felt bigger than any solo project. It’s like having a powerhouse team versus going it alone. The Police may have released their last album in 1983, but songs like “Roxanne,” “Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic,” and “Don’t Stand So Close to Me” still prove why they were unstoppable together.

David Lee Roth
In 1984, Van Halen dropped their legendary album 1984, but it was also the last time fans heard David Lee Roth fronting the band. By 1985, Roth had gone solo, and while Sammy Hagar stepped in, the magic just wasn’t the same. Roth’s wild energy and larger-than-life presence were key to Van Halen’s success, and his departure felt like the end of an era. It’s a classic case of egos clashing with creativity, leaving fans to wonder if Roth ever wishes he could “jump” back in time and rewrite history.