9 Classic Rock One-Hit Wonders with Unbearable Follow-Ups
via Annie Van Auken / YouTube
Some rock bands hit it big with one song, only to struggle with what came next. These artists delivered memorable hits, but their follow-up tracks failed to connect with listeners. Here’s a look at ten classic rock acts whose second efforts didn’t live up to their initial success.
1. Norman Greenbaum – “Spirit in the Sky” / “Canned Ham”
Norman Greenbaum’s “Spirit in the Sky” (1969) became a massive hit, blending gospel themes with rock elements. Its unique sound and spiritual lyrics resonated with a wide audience, securing its place in rock history.
However, his follow-up single, “Canned Ham,” released in 1970, failed to make a similar impact. Despite its upbeat tempo and quirky lyrics, the song didn’t chart as successfully, and Greenbaum couldn’t replicate his earlier success.
2. The Knack – “My Sharona” / “Good Girls Don’t”
The Knack’s debut single, “My Sharona” (1979), topped the charts with its catchy riff and energetic delivery. It became an anthem of the late ’70s and remains a recognizable tune.
Their next release, “Good Girls Don’t,” attempted to continue their momentum but fell short. While it had some chart presence, it didn’t capture the same widespread attention, and the band struggled to maintain their initial popularity.
3. Ram Jam – “Black Betty” / “Keep Your Hands on the Wheel”
Ram Jam’s “Black Betty” (1977) was a high-energy track that gained significant radio play. Its driving rhythm and distinctive vocals made it a standout hit.
The follow-up, “Keep Your Hands on the Wheel,” didn’t resonate with audiences in the same way. Lacking the punch of their debut, the song failed to chart significantly, and the band faded from the mainstream spotlight.
4. Starland Vocal Band – “Afternoon Delight” / “California Day”
“Afternoon Delight” (1976) by Starland Vocal Band was a soft rock hit known for its harmonious vocals and suggestive lyrics. It climbed to the top of the charts and earned the band a Grammy Award.
Their next single, “California Day,” didn’t achieve similar success. Despite its pleasant melody, it failed to chart as high, and the band’s prominence declined thereafter.
5. Tommy Tutone – “867-5309/Jenny” / “Which Man Are You”
Tommy Tutone’s “867-5309/Jenny” (1981) became a cultural phenomenon, with its catchy chorus and memorable phone number. The song’s popularity was widespread, making it a staple of early ’80s rock.
The follow-up, “Which Man Are You,” didn’t capture the same attention. Lacking the novelty and hook of their previous hit, it failed to chart significantly, and the band couldn’t sustain their earlier success.
6. Lipps Inc. – “Funkytown” / “How Long”
Lipps Inc.’s “Funkytown” (1980) was a disco-infused track that topped charts worldwide. Its infectious beat and futuristic sound made it a dance floor favorite.
Their next release, a cover of “How Long,” didn’t achieve the same acclaim. While it found some success on dance charts, it didn’t resonate with a broader audience, and the group couldn’t replicate their initial hit.
7. Five Man Electrical Band – “Signs” / “Absolutely Right”
“Signs” (1971) by Five Man Electrical Band was a protest song that struck a chord with listeners, addressing societal issues with a catchy melody. It became their signature hit.
Their follow-up, “Absolutely Right,” didn’t make the same impact. Despite its upbeat tempo, it didn’t chart as high, and the band struggled to maintain their earlier momentum.
8. Soft Cell – “Tainted Love” / “Bedsitter”
Soft Cell’s “Tainted Love” (1981) was a synth-pop cover that gained massive popularity, especially in the U.S. Its unique sound and emotional delivery made it a standout track of the era.
Their next single, “Bedsitter,” found success in the UK but didn’t chart in the U.S. Without the same international appeal, the duo couldn’t match the widespread success of their debut hit.
9. The Weather Girls – “It’s Raining Men” / “Success”
“It’s Raining Men” (1982) by The Weather Girls was a disco anthem that became a cultural touchstone. Its powerful vocals and catchy chorus made it a dance classic.
Their follow-up, “Success,” didn’t achieve similar acclaim. While it charted modestly on R&B lists, it lacked the widespread appeal of their previous hit, and the duo didn’t replicate their earlier success.
