6 Times Famous Rock Bands Tried and Failed to ‘Go Pop’

Throughout rock history, several bands have attempted to shift towards a pop sound, only to face criticism and disappointing sales. Here are six notable instances where such transitions did not go as planned.

1. U2 – Pop (1997)

In 1997, U2 released Pop, aiming to blend their rock roots with electronic dance music. The album featured tracks like “Discothèque” and “Mofo,” showcasing a departure from their earlier style. Despite debuting at number one in multiple countries, Pop received mixed reviews. Critics and fans felt the band’s experimentation compromised their signature sound. The subsequent tour faced challenges, with the band admitting the album was rushed. Over time, U2 distanced themselves from Pop, viewing it as a misstep in their discography.

2. The Rolling Stones – Dirty Work (1986)

The Rolling Stones ventured into a more polished, pop-oriented sound with their 1986 album Dirty Work. Songs like “Harlem Shuffle” attempted to capture contemporary trends. However, the album was met with lukewarm responses. Critics noted a lack of cohesion and the absence of the band’s usual energy. Tensions within the group during recording were evident, affecting the final product. Dirty Work is often cited as a low point in the Stones’ extensive catalog.

3. Genesis – Calling All Stations (1997)

After Phil Collins’ departure, Genesis released Calling All Stations in 1997, introducing a more mainstream, pop-rock approach. The album featured new vocalist Ray Wilson. Despite initial chart success, it failed to resonate with long-time fans. Critics compared it unfavorably to the band’s earlier progressive works. The lukewarm reception led to the cancellation of a planned North American tour. Genesis went on hiatus shortly after, marking this era as a challenging period in their history.

4. Fleetwood Mac – Time (1995)

In 1995, Fleetwood Mac released Time, aiming for a contemporary pop-rock sound. The album introduced new members Bekka Bramlett and Dave Mason. However, it lacked the chemistry of earlier line-ups. Critics felt the songs were uninspired, and the absence of key members like Lindsey Buckingham and Stevie Nicks was palpable. Time failed to chart in the U.S., highlighting its commercial failure. This period is often viewed as a misstep in the band’s storied career.

5. Metallica – Load (1996)

Metallica’s 1996 album Load saw the band adopting a more radio-friendly, alternative rock sound. Tracks like “Until It Sleeps” showcased a departure from their thrash metal origins. While the album sold well, it divided fans and critics. Many felt the band had strayed too far from their roots. The change in image and musical direction led to debates about authenticity. Load remains a controversial chapter in Metallica’s history.

6. The Clash – Cut the Crap (1985)

Following internal conflicts, The Clash released Cut the Crap in 1985, aiming for a more commercial sound. The album featured tracks like “This Is England,” but was marred by production issues. Critics panned its overproduction and lack of cohesion. The absence of key members like Mick Jones was evident. The album’s failure led to the band’s dissolution shortly after its release. Cut the Crap is often omitted from discussions of The Clash’s influential works.