Reasons Why These 5 Musicians Disliked Paul Simon and His Music

Paul Simon, known for pushing musical boundaries, always sought innovation in his compositions. From reimagining guitar techniques to collaborating with world musicians, Simon’s approach was unconventional. Despite his acclaim, some artists held a different view of his work.

Critics, including former bandmates and contemporaries, often questioned Simon’s artistic choices. Additionally, some prominent artists found Simon’s demeanor off-putting. Behind his iconic songs like ‘Graceland,’ a different persona emerged, one that clashed with certain artists.

Here are five artists who didn’t like Paul Simon’s music:

5. Patti Smith
During the punk revolution, Patti Smith emerged as a voice of dissent. While acknowledging Simon’s talent, she vehemently criticized Simon and Garfunkel’s music. Despite covering one of their songs, Smith expressed her aversion, citing negativity towards Simon & Garfunkel’s work.

4. Joni Mitchell
Joni Mitchell, celebrated for her lyrical prowess, found fault in Simon’s approach to songwriting. Mitchell perceived Simon’s style as verbose and lacking in subtlety, contrasting it with her meticulous craft.

3. Art Garfunkel
The duo’s success masked underlying tensions, particularly during the creation of “Bridge Over Troubled Water.” Control disputes led to their separation, with Garfunkel later expressing bewilderment at Simon’s decision to end their partnership.

2. Bob Dylan
Dylan’s encounter with Simon in England was marked by tension, culminating in a public display of disdain during one of Simon’s performances. Despite later covering one of Simon’s songs, Dylan’s actions hinted at a strained relationship.

1. John Lennon
Lennon’s clash with Simon arose from Simon’s critique of his work. Lennon retaliated, labeling Simon as inferior compared to Dylan and Mick Jagger.

Despite Simon’s contributions to music, his interactions with these artists reveal a contentious side to his legacy.