Paul McCartney Fires Back At Critics Calling His Love Songs ‘schmaltzy’

Sir Paul McCartney recently stood up for his romantic songwriting style on the podcast McCartney: A Life in Lyrics, where he discusses his inspirations with poet Paul Muldoon.

Over the years, McCartney’s penchant for love songs has drawn criticism from some who find his work “cheesy” or lacking depth. Responding to these critiques, McCartney pointed out that those who dismiss love songs might simply be unfamiliar with the feeling itself:

“I often wonder what the critic who damns it looks like, what his or her life looks like.”

Muldoon suggested that while some critics tire of McCartney’s love-themed tunes, others find fault with what they perceive as over-earnest attempts at capturing the essence of love, labeling it as “schmaltz” or lacking sophistication.

In response, McCartney shared the backstory of his hit song “Silly Love Songs,” which he wrote as a playful response to critics’ accusations of his songwriting being too sentimental. He emphasized that love is a worldly experience and defended the significance of love songs, stating:

“Love doesn’t come in a minute/ Sometimes it doesn’t come at all/ I only know that when I’m in it/ It isn’t silly/ Love isn’t silly/ Love isn’t silly at all.”

Take on the Artist’s Dilemma

McCartney also reflected on the nature of criticism, suggesting that it’s easier to gain praise by being critical and cynical rather than embracing positivity. He playfully mocked the stereotype of the angry artist, contrasting it with his own more optimistic outlook.

Addressing the tendency for artists to receive praise for cynicism, McCartney humorously contrasted his approach with the imagined reactions of critics. He highlighted the role of love as a source of strength and connection, drawing from his own experiences and observations.

Throughout the podcast, McCartney provides insight into the inspiration behind his iconic songs, offering listeners a deeper understanding of his creative process and the personal significance of his music.

Listeners can explore more of McCartney’s reflections on his life and lyrics through McCartney: A Life in Lyrics, available on major streaming platforms.