5 Lead Singers Who Were Fired From Their Own Bands

Throughout rock history, several lead singers have been dismissed from the very bands they helped define. These departures often stem from personal conflicts, creative differences, or lifestyle issues. Here are five notable instances:

1. Ozzy Osbourne and Black Sabbath

Ozzy Osbourne co-founded Black Sabbath in 1968, becoming a pioneer of heavy metal with his distinctive voice and stage presence. However, by 1979, Osbourne’s escalating substance abuse and erratic behavior led to tensions within the band. The other members felt his unreliability was hindering their progress, resulting in his dismissal. Despite this setback, Osbourne embarked on a successful solo career, while Black Sabbath continued with new vocalists. Years later, Osbourne reunited with the band for various projects, highlighting the complex dynamics of their relationship.

2. Dave Evans and AC/DC

Dave Evans was the original lead singer for AC/DC, joining the Australian rock band in 1973. During his tenure, the group released their debut single, but internal disagreements and dissatisfaction with Evans’ stage presence led to his departure in 1974. He was replaced by Bon Scott, under whose leadership AC/DC achieved international fame. Evans continued his music career with other bands, but his brief stint with AC/DC remains a notable chapter in rock history.

3. Paul Di’Anno and Iron Maiden

Paul Di’Anno served as Iron Maiden’s lead vocalist from 1978 to 1981, contributing to their early success with his raw, punk-influenced style. However, his erratic behavior and substance abuse issues created friction within the band. In 1981, after recording two albums, Di’Anno was dismissed and replaced by Bruce Dickinson. Post-Iron Maiden, Di’Anno faced personal and legal challenges but maintained a dedicated fan base through various musical projects.

4. Steve Perry and Journey

Steve Perry joined Journey in 1977, propelling the band to new heights with his powerful vocals on hits like “Don’t Stop Believin'” and “Open Arms.” Despite the commercial success, internal conflicts and Perry’s health issues created rifts within the group. In 1997, after a prolonged hiatus and failed attempts to reconcile differences, Journey made the difficult decision to continue without Perry. This move allowed the band to resume touring and recording, while Perry pursued solo endeavors, marking a significant shift in Journey’s lineup and sound.

5. Syd Barrett and Pink Floyd

Syd Barrett, born Roger Keith Barrett in 1946, co-founded Pink Floyd in 1965 and was the band’s original frontman and primary songwriter. His innovative guitar work and whimsical lyrics were central to the band’s early psychedelic sound. However, by 1968, Barrett’s behavior became increasingly erratic, largely attributed to his heavy use of psychedelic drugs and possible mental health issues. During performances, he would often play the same chord repeatedly or not play at all, leading to unpredictable and challenging live shows. The situation escalated to the point where the band decided to bring in David Gilmour as a second guitarist to cover for Barrett. Eventually, the band made the difficult decision to part ways with Barrett to continue their musical journey. Despite his departure, Barrett’s influence remained, inspiring later works like “Shine On You Crazy Diamond,” a tribute to their troubled former leader.