How Dixie Chick’s “Landslide” Cover Almost Derailed Fleetwood Mac

Nearly 30 years after Fleetwood Mac introduced the world to “Landslide” on their 1975 self-titled album, country music trio The Chicks (then known as the Dixie Chicks) offered their own take on the reflective classic. With the addition of banjo and their signature tight harmonies, The Chicks transformed Stevie Nicks’ heartfelt ballad into a rendition that resonated deeply with the country music audience while retaining its emotional core.

“Landslide” Finds a New Home in Country Music

The Chicks’ version of “Landslide,” featured on their 2002 album Home, marked a career milestone. It became their first and only No. 1 hit on the Billboard Adult Contemporary chart and performed impressively elsewhere, reaching No. 7 on the Billboard Hot 100, No. 2 on Adult Pop Airplay, and No. 2 on Hot Country Songs.

The song’s seamless transition into the country genre was a testament to its timelessness. However, not everyone was enthusiastic about the implications of this crossover.

Lindsey Buckingham’s Concerns

For Fleetwood Mac guitarist Lindsey Buckingham, The Chicks’ cover sparked apprehension about how it might influence the band’s identity. In a 2003 Guitar World interview, Buckingham expressed unease, saying, “It’s a great song, but I don’t want anyone to get the funny idea about Fleetwood Mac and country.” He noted that discussions within the band’s label about appearing on Country Music Television pushed him to draw a line. “There’s a certain kind of profile you want to put out there. And that isn’t it.”

While Buckingham resisted any perception of Fleetwood Mac as leaning toward country, his reaction highlighted the protective nature of an artist over their band’s legacy.

Stevie Nicks Embraces the Cover

In contrast to Buckingham’s concerns, Stevie Nicks, who wrote “Landslide” in the early 1970s, fully embraced The Chicks’ interpretation. During a 2002 interview with CMT.com, Nicks shared her enthusiasm, recalling her experience performing the song alongside The Chicks at VH1’s Divas Las Vegas. “I love it,” she said. “Singing it with the girls and creating a four-part harmony was such a treat.”

Nicks also reflected on the song’s journey and enduring relevance, recounting its creation in 1973 during a quiet moment in Colorado. She said:

“I remember sitting in a beautiful house, writing ‘Landslide,’ seeing it through my eyes as a young woman in my early 20s. Now, seeing it evolve through you guys’ eyes, it’s an amazing metamorphosis.
“From generation to generation, this song has a life of its own, and I’m so proud to be part of it.”

A Song That Transcends Time

The Chicks’ cover of “Landslide” illustrates the song’s remarkable adaptability and emotional resonance across genres and generations. While Lindsey Buckingham’s reservations reflected a desire to preserve Fleetwood Mac’s identity, Stevie Nicks’ wholehearted support highlighted her appreciation for the song’s universal appeal. Together, their perspectives underscore the lasting legacy of a song that continues to captivate listeners, no matter the era or interpretation.