The 5 Biggest U.S. Hits of Carly Simon’s Legendary Career

Carly Simon was one of those rare singers who made you feel like she was singing straight from the heart. Her voice became a defining part of the 1970s soundtrack—warm, intelligent, and sometimes unflinchingly honest. She could swing from sad to funny in a single stanza, and she always sounded like she meant every word.

Let’s revisit five of her biggest U.S. hits—songs that made her famous and still sound just as fresh today.

1. “That’s the Way I’ve Always Heard It Should Be” (1971)
When Carly Simon began her career, she didn’t play it safe. Her debut hit, “That’s the Way I’ve Always Heard It Should Be,” was anything but a typical first single. Instead of a catchy pop tune, she released a haunting reflection on the pressure to settle down and live the “perfect” life.

Jacob Brackman wrote the lyrics, which explore the uncomfortable moment when you begin to question whether the traditional path—marriage, kids, the white picket fence—is truly meant for you. Simon composed the music, and the slow, contemplative melody mirrors the lyrical doubt. Her voice is both fragile and strong, lending a raw honesty that resonated deeply. The song reached No. 10 on the charts, proving Simon wasn’t just another pretty voice—she had something real to say.

2. “Mockingbird” (1974)
By 1974, Carly Simon and James Taylor were the golden couple of the music world. Their duet “Mockingbird,” a spirited cover of the 1960s R&B hit by Inez and Charlie Foxx, let them show a more playful side.

They sounded like two people genuinely enjoying themselves as they traded verses and harmonized. Dr. John added dynamic flair on piano, and Robbie Robertson’s guitar work gave the song extra depth. It climbed to No. 5 on the Billboard charts and became one of their most beloved collaborations. “Mockingbird” might have been lighthearted, but it proved Simon could let loose and still shine.

3. “Nobody Does It Better” (1977)
Singing a James Bond theme is no small task, but Carly Simon made it seem effortless. “Nobody Does It Better,” written by Marvin Hamlisch and Carole Bayer Sager for The Spy Who Loved Me, was the perfect showcase for Simon’s expressive, elegant voice.

The song plays as both a love letter and a warning about a charming but untrustworthy man. Simon’s smooth, confident delivery gave every lyric a sense of personal experience. The result was timeless, connecting with listeners well beyond the Bond universe. It reached No. 2 on the charts and earned an Oscar nomination. More importantly, it became one of those unforgettable songs that you can’t help but sing along to, even decades later.

4. “You Belong to Me” (1978)
Carly Simon had a knack for collaboration, and when she teamed up with Michael McDonald in the late ’70s, the result was pure magic. McDonald brought his signature smoothness, while Simon contributed sharp lyrics and a commanding presence.

Although the Doobie Brothers recorded their version first, Simon’s take had a spark all its own. Her rendition was bolder and sassier, with just the right mix of attitude and charm. You can almost hear her raise an eyebrow when she sings, “Why’d you tell her that you love her?” Snappy, fun, and daring—exactly what a great pop song of that era should be. The song reached No. 6, reaffirming Simon’s staying power on the charts.

5. “You’re So Vain” (1972)
And then there’s the song that everyone still talks about. “You’re So Vain” wasn’t just a Carly Simon hit—it became a pop culture phenomenon. Released in 1972, it shot to No. 1 and sparked endless speculation about the identity of the mystery man it skewers.

Even without the gossip, the song stands on its own. The groove is smooth, the production is tight, and Simon’s vocal performance blends sarcasm with strength. Mick Jagger provided uncredited backing vocals, adding another layer of intrigue and tension. But it’s Simon’s delivery that makes the song iconic—she sounds amused, angry, and completely in control all at once. It’s more than a breakup song; it’s a declaration of self-respect.

Over fifty years later, people still sing along, still debate its subject, and still feel the same electric thrill in every line.

The Lasting Power of Carly Simon

Carly Simon’s music endures because she never shied away from being herself. She could be sad, hilarious, furious, or romantic—all in the same song—and it always felt genuine.

Listeners searching for clarity in love and life found a kindred spirit in her songs, and they still do. Simon made honesty sound beautiful, whether she was questioning traditions, calling out an ex, or reveling in the joy of connection.

Maybe that’s why—after all these years—nobody really does it better.