7 Classic Rock Bands That Should Have Been Bigger

Many classic rock bands from the 60s and 70s became household names, but some, despite their talent and unique sound, never achieved the mainstream success they deserved. These bands had the potential to be huge but, for various reasons, remained underrated or overshadowed. Here are seven bands that should have been bigger in the rock world.

1. Mott the Hoople

Mott the Hoople, led by frontman Ian Hunter, combined glam rock with hard-hitting guitar riffs. Their 1972 hit “All the Young Dudes,” written by David Bowie, became an anthem, but the band never reached the level of success their music warranted. Despite their unique sound, they struggled to stay in the limelight.

Internal conflicts and frequent lineup changes held them back from reaching their full potential. Although they earned a dedicated fanbase, they never broke into the same commercial success enjoyed by their peers in the glam rock scene, like T. Rex or David Bowie.

2. Love

Love was a pioneering band in the psychedelic rock scene of the 1960s. Their album “Forever Changes” is often praised for its intricate arrangements and thoughtful lyrics. The band blended rock, folk, and orchestral elements to create a distinctive sound.

Despite critical acclaim, Love never became a mainstream success. Internal conflicts and management problems hindered their ability to promote their music effectively. As a result, their innovative work didn’t receive the widespread attention it deserved.

3. Big Star

Big Star, formed in the early 70s, influenced countless future alternative and power-pop bands. Despite critical acclaim for albums like #1 Record and Radio City, they struggled to gain commercial success. Their melodic sound and sharp songwriting should have catapulted them to stardom, but distribution problems and poor promotion hindered their rise.

Though not widely recognized in their time, Big Star’s music gained a cult following and posthumous praise. Bands like R.E.M. and The Replacements cited them as major influences, proving that their legacy lived on, even if their commercial success didn’t.

4. Humble Pie

Led by Steve Marriott, Humble Pie was a hard rock band with a bluesy edge that earned respect but never quite reached the fame of similar bands of the era. Known for powerful live performances and hits like “30 Days in the Hole,” they had all the ingredients for massive success but never fully broke through.

The band faced various struggles, including management issues and constant touring, which took a toll on their momentum. Humble Pie deserved to be a bigger name in rock, but their potential was never fully realized before internal tensions led to their eventual breakup.

5. Moby Grape

Moby Grape emerged in the late 1960s with a blend of rock, blues, and country influences. Their self-titled debut album was highly acclaimed for its diversity and musicianship. The band had the talent to make a significant impact on the rock scene.

Unfortunately, Moby Grape faced numerous challenges, including legal battles and management problems. These issues prevented them from capitalizing on their early success, resulting in a career that didn’t reach its full potential.

6. The Zombies

The Zombies formed in the 1960s and quickly gained attention with their unique sound. Their song “Time of the Season” became a hit, showcasing their strong vocals and catchy melodies. Despite their talent, they never reached the same level of fame as other bands from their era.

After their initial success, the band struggled with internal issues and changing musical trends. Although they reunited and continued to perform, The Zombies remained underrated in the broader rock scene, leaving many music lovers wishing they had achieved greater popularity.

7. Spirit

Spirit was known for their innovative music that combined rock, jazz, and folk elements. Songs like “I Got a Line on You” and “Nature’s Way” highlighted their creative approach and musicianship. The band was respected by peers and critics alike.

Despite their talent, Spirit didn’t achieve widespread commercial success. Changes in the music industry and a lack of consistent promotion limited their reach. Today, they are remembered fondly by fans, but many believe they deserved a larger audience.