5 Classic Rock Drummers That Couldn’t Keep Time
via Dutch Generation X / YouTube
Classic rock has given us unforgettable tunes and legendary performers who’ve left a massive impact on music history. Yet, even in bands that have achieved nearly mythical status, not every member has always hit the mark. Today, we’re zoning in on a curious aspect of rock music history – drummers known for their charismatic stage presence and powerful solos, but who also had moments when keeping time was a challenge. Their struggles with rhythm didn’t stop their bands from achieving greatness, but it’s an interesting chapter in the saga of rock ‘n’ roll.
1. Peter Criss of Kiss
View this post on Instagram
Kiss, known for their face paint and elaborate stage shows, also had moments of less-than-stellar musicianship behind the glitz. Peter Criss, the original drummer, found himself in hot water with fans and critics alike for his rhythmic inconsistencies during live performances. It wasn’t just about hitting the drums hard; keeping a steady beat was crucial, and Criss often wavered, especially in the adrenaline-fueled environment of a Kiss concert.
This was noticeable in both concert footage and some studio recordings, where the tempo would sometimes shift mid-song. While Kiss’s theatrical performances and catchy hooks often masked these issues, dedicated listeners and musicians could pick out moments where Criss’s timing didn’t quite align with the band. Despite this, Criss’s energy and charisma never waned, embodying the spirit of Kiss through every performance.
2. Alex Van Halen of Van Halen
View this post on Instagram
Alex Van Halen, co-founder of the rock band Van Halen with his brother Eddie, is known for his powerful drumming and intricately constructed solos. While celebrated for his technical proficiency and driving rhythms, there have been occasional live performances where maintaining consistent timing was challenging. The high-octane environment of Van Halen’s performances, combined with the technical complexity of their music, sometimes led to these instances.
Despite any challenges with timing, Alex Van Halen’s drumming has been a backbone of Van Halen’s sound, contributing heavily to the band’s success. His innovative techniques and ability to craft memorable drum parts have earned him a place among rock’s drumming elite. His influence extends far beyond the confines of rock music, inspiring countless drummers with his dynamic style and musicality.
3. Steven Adler of Guns N’ Roses
View this post on Instagram
Guns N’ Roses shot to fame in the late ’80s, with Steven Adler behind the drum kit during their meteoric rise. Adler’s hard-hitting style suited the band’s gritty, hard rock sound. Yet, it was no secret within the music community that timing inconsistencies occasionally plagued live performances. The energy and raw power of Guns N’ Roses often overshadowed these moments, but they were apparent to those with a keen ear for rhythm.
Despite these challenges, Adler’s contributions to the band’s classic tracks remain undisputed. His drumming on hits like “Sweet Child o’ Mine” and “Welcome to the Jungle” captured the spirit of an era. Adler’s struggle with timing is a footnote in the band’s storied career, overshadowed by his powerhouse performances and the group’s massive success.
4. Lars Ulrich of Metallica
View this post on Instagram
Metallica, one of the leading bands in the thrash metal genre, features Lars Ulrich on the drums. Known for his aggressive playing style and for being a founding member of the band, Ulrich has faced criticism over the years for his timing live on stage. In the high-speed, intensely precise world of metal, timing is everything, and even slight discrepancies can be glaring.
Despite this, Ulrich’s energy and creativity have never been in question. He’s often spearheaded the band’s direction, both musically and in the music business. Metallica’s live performances are electrifying, with Ulrich’s drumming fueling the band’s signature sound. Even with occasional timing issues, his role in propelling Metallica to global fame is undeniable.
5. Ringo Starr of The Beatles
View this post on Instagram
Ringo Starr, the drummer for The Beatles, often faces underestimation for his contributions to the band’s music. Critics and fans have pointed out moments of simplistic playing or minor timing missteps in the band’s vast discography. However, Starr’s style was exactly what The Beatles needed — serving the song first, with a focus on feel rather than technical complexity.
Starr’s playing on songs like “Come Together” and “Rain” showcases his ability to create memorable, musical drum parts that serve the song perfectly. While he may not have been the flashiest drummer of his time, his knack for rhythm and melody made him an integral piece of the Beatles puzzle. Despite the critiques, Starr’s musicality and timing were key elements in some of the most beloved songs in rock history.
