In Defense of the ‘Worst’: 4 Classic Rock Songs Fans Will Die On a Hill For

Let’s be honest: every famous rock band has at least one song that makes people go, “What?” You know—the songs that make fans think, “Wait, really?” Maybe they weren’t popular enough, or maybe they were just too strange for their time. Either way, they’ve landed on the “most hated” list at some point.

But here’s the thing: a song doesn’t have to be terrible just because it’s weird or didn’t catch on. A lot of these so-called “misfires” are actually full of originality, charm, and individuality. Some music fans might dismiss them, but for a few, they’re hidden gems.

Here are four iconic rock songs that are often considered awful—but some fans love every second of them.

“Temporary Secretary” by Paul McCartney
The One With All the Synths
People either skip or obsess over Paul McCartney’s “Temporary Secretary.” Released on his McCartney II album, this track dives deep into synth territory with a wild, almost comical energy. It’s strange, catchy, and completely out there. Some fans can’t get enough of its quirky appeal, while others roll their eyes. Love it or hate it, it’s unforgettable.

“Circle of Power” by Soundgarden
Grunge Meets Punk Mayhem
“Circle of Power” is loud, fast, and messy—but in the best way possible. From Soundgarden’s early work, it feels like the band just let loose in the studio. Some call it a parody of hardcore punk; others see it as the band having pure, chaotic fun. Either way, it’s a short blast of energy that some fans secretly admire for its boldness.

“Bonehead’s Bank Holiday” by Oasis
The Goofy Pub Singalong
This Oasis B-side isn’t polished—and that’s what makes it great. The lyrics to “Bonehead’s Bank Holiday” are silly, the structure is loose, and it sounds like it was recorded during a tipsy, late-night jam session. It’s messy, loud, and unexpectedly endearing—like a tune you’d sing with friends at the end of a long night. Not deep or serious, but definitely charming.

“Bugs” by Pearl Jam
Accordion, Rambling—and Somehow It Works
This might be the strangest song on the list. “Bugs” features Eddie Vedder ranting about bugs over a droning accordion and a single chord. It sounds like something from a dream—or maybe a fever. Is it weird? Absolutely. But there’s a hypnotic, surreal quality to it. For some, it’s a bold experiment that deserves more appreciation than it gets.