3 Classic Rock Covers Their Original Artists Couldn’t Stand

Cover songs are a big part of rock history. Some become more famous than the originals, while others miss the mark. Usually, a cover is a way to honor a song. But not every artist likes what others do with their work. In fact, a few musicians have been very open about how much they disliked certain versions of their songs. Whether it’s a lyric change, a different sound, or just a bad match, these classic rock covers didn’t sit well with the original artists. Here are three real examples where the original creators were less than thrilled.

“Where the Streets Have No Name (I Can’t Take My Eyes Off You)” by Pet Shop Boys – Single (1991)

In 1991, Pet Shop Boys released a mashup of U2’s “Where the Streets Have No Name” and Frankie Valli’s “Can’t Take My Eyes Off You.” The track mixed electronic pop with two classic songs in an unexpected way. While fans of synth-pop enjoyed the new sound, Bono of U2 was not pleased at the time.

Bono reportedly said, “What have we done to deserve this?” in response to the song. He didn’t like how it changed the tone of U2’s original, which was a serious anthem. However, the mood softened over time. Bono later made peace with the band, and the cover has since become a favorite among many ’90s pop fans.

“Blinded By The Light” by Manfred Mann’s Earth Band – The Roaring Silence (1976)

Bruce Springsteen released “Blinded by the Light” in 1973 on his debut album Greetings from Asbury Park, N.J. It was one of his early tracks full of sharp lyrics and energy. In 1976, Manfred Mann’s Earth Band covered the song and changed some of the lyrics. Most notably, the line “revved up like a deuce” was heard by many as “wrapped up like a douche,” causing confusion and jokes.

Springsteen later said he wasn’t a fan of the cover, mostly due to the altered lyrics. Still, Manfred Mann’s version went on to top the Billboard Hot 100, becoming more commercially successful than Springsteen’s original. Despite the hit status, the lyric change bugged Bruce for years and took away the meaning he intended. Even so, he admitted it brought more attention to his earlier work.

“You Really Got Me” by Van Halen – Van Halen (1978)

The Kinks released “You Really Got Me” in 1964, and it became one of the most important early rock songs, known for its raw guitar sound. In 1978, Van Halen recorded their version for their self-titled debut album. Their take had heavier guitar, a faster pace, and a polished production style that made it a rock radio staple in the U.S.

Dave Davies of The Kinks later said there was a “chasm between the two versions.” Though he appreciated the attention and said it was flattering in a way, he also pointed out that Van Halen’s version missed the feel of the original. He believed it lacked the grit and attitude that made the song what it was in 1964.