11 of the Most Expensive Jimmy Buffett Items Recently Sold

Jimmy Buffett, the legendary musician known for his laid-back island vibes, has captured the hearts of fans worldwide for decades. While his music has provided the soundtrack to countless beach vacations and backyard barbecues, there’s another side to Jimmy Buffett that’s gaining attention—his collectibles.

In this article, we’ll take a closer look at the top 11 most expensive items recently sold from Jimmy Buffett’s collection, giving us a glimpse into the world of music memorabilia.

1. A Baseball Signed by Buffett Himself ($1,499)
First on the list is a baseball signed by Jimmy Buffett, a unique piece of memorabilia that stands out in a world typically dominated by athlete autographs. The $1,499 price tag might raise eyebrows, but for devoted fans, owning a piece of Buffett’s signature is priceless. While it may seem like a simple item, it carries the allure of being part of Buffett’s collection, making it a cherished keepsake for a lucky collector.

2. Margaritaville Sandal Shadow Box ($1,500)
Number 10 on the list takes us to an unexpected treasure—a Margaritaville sandal carefully arranged in a shadow box. This unique display, complete with a pre-show sticker and ticket stub, fetched a cool $1,500. It’s a testament to the creativity of fans who turn everyday items into priceless memorabilia.

3. 1979 Volcano Promo Store Display ($1,500)
Nostalgia takes center stage with this 1979 Volcano promo store display, which was sold for the same price—$1,500. Such items tap into the emotions of fans who remember the era when Buffett’s music was at its peak.

4. Platinum Award for ‘Changes in Latitudes’ ($1,625)
A platinum award for Changes in Latitudes from 1977 takes the eighth spot on our list, fetching $1,625 at auction. This award, featuring the cassette, CD, vinyl record, and a guitar pick, is a must-have for any die-hard Jimmy Buffett collector.

5. Personalized Jimmy Buffett Album ($2,500)
At number seven, we find a personalized Jimmy Buffett album with a heartfelt message. It’s a reminder that personal connections with an artist can add immense value to memorabilia, especially when the artist is no longer with us.

6. Signed Tom Sawyer Concert Contract ($2,500)
For fans who appreciate the behind-the-scenes magic, a signed Tom Sawyer concert contract from 1976 is a gem. This intricate piece, accompanied by a certificate of authenticity, sold for $2,500.

7. Vintage Jimmy Buffett Poster ($3,000)
A true piece of history, a vintage Jimmy Buffett poster from the 1970s takes the fifth spot on our list. Despite a few imperfections, it’s a testament to the enduring appeal of original, vintage memorabilia.

8. Jimmy Buffett Cruise Flyer (1976)
Number four brings us a Jimmy Buffett concert poster from the Tom Sawyer cruise in 1976. This flyer, promoting Wine and Dine Under the Stars, is a rare find, representing a time when such items were often discarded.

9. Autographed Album with Letter of Authenticity ($3,000)
Another signed album, this one featuring the message “Best wishes, Jimmy Buffett,” along with a letter of authenticity, fetched $3,000. The increasing value of Buffett’s autograph serves as a reminder of his lasting influence.

10. Margaritaville Canvas Art Piece ($5,000)
Number two takes us to a captivating Margaritaville canvas art piece signed by Jimmy Buffett himself. Numbered 37 of 50 and accompanied by photos of Buffett signing the pieces, it’s a testament to the artist’s connection with his fans, fetching $5,000.

11. Jimmy Buffett Martin Guitar ($7,600)
Finally, the pinnacle of Jimmy Buffett collectibles—an exclusive Martin guitar, numbered 39 of 305, went under the hammer for an impressive $7,600. This exquisite instrument is the ultimate find for a guitar-playing Jimmy Buffett enthusiast.

These top 11 most expensive items sold from Buffett’s collection showcase the enduring allure of music memorabilia and the deep connection fans have with their favorite artists. Whether it’s a signed album, a vintage poster, or a Martin guitar, these items carry not just a price but a piece of history and a dash of the Margaritaville magic.